Betamax or VHS

11 Apr – May and I were having dinner with Ah Tat, Ah Ting & Siew Mei when we were discussing about VHS and Siew Mei excitedly mentioned that her dad still watches VHS back in her home town. She added that her family can still rent the latest Hong Kong serials in VHS format. While expressing wonder that VHS serials are still available, I mentioned about Betamax tapes were the original tapes for the video technology. Ah Tat, Ah Ting & Siew Mei looked at me blankly.


You know Betamax tapes, smaller that VHS tapes?”, I exclaimed.

All three faces were totally blank.



In my mind, it was not possible not to know about Betamax. After all, they were born in the seventies. Then it dawned upon me that the difference was that I was born in the sixties. While feeling a bit older but I felt a bit wiser and experienced.  I then tried to explaining about Betamax to three equally unimpressed DVD users. It was like trying to explain the Morse Code to internet users.



Thinking back, those of us who were born in the sixties had actually seen it all from Betamax through the VHS era to VCD, DVD and Blu Ray.



It all started in 1975 when Sony released the first Betamax tape for home video. Sony tried to monopolise the market with the Betamax technology but JVC refused to accept Sony’s dominance and introduced their own video format in 1976 called the VHS (Video Home System) while Philips released their Video2000 in 1980. By the early 1980s there an intense video war between Betamax and VHS.  





As consumers, we will always remember Betamax (above picture top) as the more compact tape as compared with VHS (above picture bottom) and the first users of Betamax would claim rightly that pictures from Betamax was clearer which was true as Betamax ran on a higher definition as compared with VHS.



What caused Betamax to lose the market was Sony’s marketing strategy where they tried to corner the video market with a technological superior product without considering the consumers’ behaviour. When their rivals refused to accept Sony’s dominance and joined forces to market JVC’s VHS, it was literally Sony versus the rest of the world.



Finally, what killed the Betamax was the limited recording time where the producers of VHS produced a 2 hours recording tape to suit the length of standard feature movies and was an immediate hit.



By the time, Sony realised their shortcomings, VHS has taken over 75% of the market. Sony tried to match the 2 hours recording by slowdown the running speed but in doing so, compromised on the superior quality which Betamax had. That move was the final straw that broke the back. By then, VHS upped the standard further by introducing 3 hours and 4 hours tape.



By 2002, Betamax died a natural death. VHS had won the battle but not the war with the introduction of VCD and DVD. In 2007, all major manufacturers has stopped production of dedicated VHS players and concentrated their efforts in DVD players and DVD Recorders.



It is only a matter of time, Siew Mei’s family will have no choice but to switch to DVDs or perhaps some other new media as the world of technology has never been more fluid.


This entry was posted in Life and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to Betamax or VHS

  1. Pink Jeans says:

    Well, Sony has won the game this time, together with other members of the Blu Ray Disc Association as Toshiba has conceded and will no longer produce HD DVD format. Personally, I’m a Sony fan – prefer devices that use Memory Stick as opposed to other storage media. I guess I just want to maximise the Memory Sticks I have and simplify matters in terms of interchangeability. I’m such a sucker, right??

  2. shorthorse says:

    Asme: Well, I was born in the ’60’s but never used betamax either. Went straight into the VHS market!

    As for Pink Jeans comments on interchangeability I think this is limited to certain peripheral items only – take handphones and cameras for example… peripherals like batteries & chargers should by right be interchangeable if you upgrade to models of the same brand. Alas, this is not the case…

  3. Gina says:

    Eh.. I have never seen a betamax in my entire life till I read this from your blog. Haha!!!

  4. asme says:

    Pink Jeans – Actually Sony did not lose out in the Betamax war, they improvised and used the technology for the digicam with their Betacam tapes. They managed to dominate that market for 15 years until now. Technology has caught up and manufacturers are using hard disk for the purpose. So it is back to the drawing board for Sony.

    As for Blu Ray, it is the ‘in’ thing now but in Asia, it has not caught on, purely because the pirates has problem to pirate it. LOL.

    SH & Gina – My gawd, you guy have never had or seen a Betamax? Actually it was rare and I only knew two people who owned one. One of them happened to be my ex-girlfriend. Used to spend a lot of time watching Betamax in her home back in the 80’s.
    Ha.Ha. That’s more than 20 years ago.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s